by Seismic Sam on Sat May 04, 2013 9:48 am
To answer the OP, my answer is "Nope, not worth the time or money". I have gone the boiling water w/lemon juice route and have never looked back. No, it does not get case factory bright like corn cob or SS pins, but it's pretty darn good and about MUCH faster and simpler, and the cases are really clean! I can resize/deprime hundreds of boiled cases, and my fingers are barely dirty, so there's no significant gunk left. I can do 400 45 and 400 40 cases in under 20 minutes and even use the same water, and after they sit in my gas oven overnight with just the pilot light on they are dry and ready to go. 800 cases in 20 minutes = 1.5 seconds spent per case, while 800 cases in 6 hours = 27 seconds per case. That makes boiling cases in water and lemon juice 18X faster, plus the only equipment you need is a 2 gallon pan, a slotted spoon, and a couple of glass pyrex trays to dry the brass in. Way less up front expenditure, way less stuff sitting around, no buzzing or clacking noise in your reloading area for 6 hours to boot. Reloading with that vibratory bowl tumbler going was a real PITA, so I couldn't have a pleasant reloading session with my tunes on with that damn thing buzzing away at the same time.