by Seismic Sam on Wed Dec 07, 2011 3:24 am
Okay, the neck sizing vs. full length sizing data are in conflict with Oldman's advice NOT to expand the neck, and I'm pretty sure I know why. Had a helluva time setting up my .338 Ultramag brass, and my primary big mistake was to order a .338 Ultramag Lee collet die, which has a depriming rod with pin in the middle, and then four collet fingers that come in and size the neck only while the depriming rod is stuck down the flash hole. It was so simple it seemed foolproof. I was having trouble chambering my rounds after neck resizing with this Lee die, and my SMK bullets are seated 20 mils off the lands. Bought an RCBS runout measurer, and then a neck turning set, and then a Redding type S neck sizing die, and went through hundreds of dollars in bullets and primers and powders trying to keep my runout under 1 mil. Turns out that my fired cases were under 1 mil runout, so the rifle chamber was concentric. After sizing with the @%$$*%#$#$%^ Lee collet die, the runout could INCREASE by up to 5 mils. While it wasn't as bad, the Redding Type S die did the same damn thing! The only thing that produced concentric cases was a plain old Redding FL steel resize die. At this point, I decided to duplicate and old Bonanza (from Owatonna, no less!) benchrest .223 die that had the neck expander ball as far up in the die as you could get it without the case jamming in the die. As such, when you withdrew the case from the die, the neck portion of the case was still supported by the die while it ran over the expander. The result was nearly perfect concentric brass with the proper ID neck size. I'm sure Oldman must have a benchrest seating die with a floating collet that holds the case in exact alignment with the bullet, so when you seat the bullet it can't go off center. But his advice not to expand the neck is valid UNLESS you are using the old Bonanza system, because OD neck sizing alone or ID neck sizing alone CAN make the neck go off center.
Based on the data presented, the group size reduction by uniforming the primer pocket and flash hole seem to have a noticable effect on accuracy, so I may be off to Gunstop in the near future. I wouldn't have believed that uniforming the primer flash hole could have that much effect, but maybe it does.