qualcorp wrote:Anyone care to share their favorite 40 recipes? I will be using the Blue dot, with a 180gr. / 155gr. bullet, just setting the machine up now and looking at different websites for ideas, it seems they are all over the board on this could be touchy round. Thoughts ?
BTW This will be my first at loading 40's.
Well, seeing as you told the n00b to spin into butter, and you're asking a serious, specific question, I'll give you a serious answer. Yes, the 40 is touchy, and in particular if the bullet sets back upon feeding, it can greatly jack the pressure and blow the gun. Not trying to start the old Tupperware rant all over again, but because of a lack of chamber support there is a reasonably high correlation between the earlier Gen 40 Glocks and KABOOMS. Surf the web and you'll find them all over the place.
As such, you need to be dead nuts on with your crimp technique, to the point that you need at least three mils crimp or maybe four. and this isn't a guessing game. Set your crimp, then pull the bullet, and measure the depth of the groove the case left in the bullet. that's the only way to know for sure what you're getting. And if I were you, I would invest in a Lee Factory crimp die, and DO NOT try to seat and crimp with one die!! You have to get a die set dead nuts on both in the press and the seating stem itself, and if you're asking for advice then you're not experienced enough to pull this off. I have described this procedure in another post in deatil, if you care to find it, but I still would NOT do this myself with a single seating/crimp die, even through I know how.
Secondly, yes you are getting load data all over the map, and I would hope ythat you have at least TWO reloading manuals to refer to, and remember that getting load data off the internet can be very dicey. In particular, the Alliant website, for whatever reason, only lists MAX loads for a lot of stuff, and their MAX loads are the real balls-to-the-wall data, and if you go beyond that your cases will start bulging a few tenths of a grain higher!! Dunno why they do it that way, but they do.
My Hornady #9 manual says for 155 grain JHP, the range for Blue Dot is 8.2 to 10.2 grains, and for 180 grain JHP/FMJ-FP the range is 6.4 - 8.3 grs. In all cases COL is 1.125" It's only when you get into FMJ-Round Nose that the COL gets longer.
FWIW, the original design spec for the 40 S&W was a 180 grain bullet going 980 FPS, and this was the original FBI requested loading for the FBI agents who were getting hurty wrists with the 10mm. The 40 is NOT a round that can be-hot rodded, unlike its older and bigger parent, the 10mm. As such, you want to stick to the specs and NEVER exceed them. If you wanted the ability to go hotter and experiment more, then you need to buy a 10mm, and I would personally get one that's ALL steel.
The 40 and 10mm have the same relationship that the 38 Special and 357 mag have, but while the weaker 38 Special came first, in .400 bullet diameter the 10mm came first and then its Shorter & Weaker sibling. While the SAAMI pressure for the 40 is 35,000 PSI and the 10mm is 37,500, which is not a big difference, I think there is a HUGE difference in the construction of 40 and 10 guns, with the 40 being a 38 Special duty round and the 10mm being a smoking hot hunting/max ft-lb round. So watch your butt, because the 40 is a watered down 10 with a hard upper ceiling, while a 10 was the original Jeff Cooper design with upper limits that were not that strict.