Li'l Beaver wrote:While we are debating the "Voter ID Act" Let me ask how many legal citizens DO NOT have some sort of photo ID?
Heffay wrote:According to Pennsylvania, the answer is in the hundreds of thousands.
Li'l Beaver wrote:While we are debating the "Voter ID Act" Let me ask how many legal citizens DO NOT have some sort of photo ID? It is nearly impossible to do many daily tasks without producing a photo ID. Cashing a check, buying alcoholic beverages, buying tobacco products, securing a loan for a house or vehicle, going to the doctor, being admitted to the hospital, being issued a business license, or simply driving a vehicle most of these require a government issued photo ID!
Li'l Beaver wrote:I will say that in nearly seventy years of voting in every election there were less than half a dozen times I had to spend over twenty minutes waiting to cast my votes.
Careful. This is the same reasoning used by people who want to see more restrictions on gun rights. "I have to get a license to drive a car, why not to buy a gun?!?" So make sure you're consistent in your reasoning. Likewise, there are plenty of other parallels. How much do you want to limit the exercise of liberties of the law abiding to protect against bad actors who abuse their freedom? Are you comfortable with more government record keeping to prevent malfeasance?oldhunter wrote:No ID to vote, but yet when I go to the eye doctor they tell me to bring my medicare card, my supplemental insurance card and a photo ID. All so when I went to get laser surgery on my eye the surgery center wanted the same. When I asked about it, the reason was all the fraud going on in medicare. So us old duffers have to have a photo ID to go to a doctor, but we can't seem to find one to vote?
oldhunter wrote:
No ID to vote, but yet when I go to the eye doctor they tell me to bring my medicare card, my supplemental insurance card and a photo ID. All so when I went to get laser surgery on my eye the surgery center wanted the same. When I asked about it, the reason was all the fraud going on in medicare. So us old duffers have to have a photo ID to go to a doctor, but we can't seem to find one to vote?
Careful. This is the same reasoning used by people who want to see more restrictions on gun rights. "I have to get a license to drive a car, why not to buy a gun?!?" So make sure you're consistent in your reasoning. Likewise, there are plenty of other parallels. How much do you want to limit the exercise of liberties of the law abiding to protect against bad actors who abuse their freedom? Are you comfortable with more government record keeping to prevent malfeasance?
Icmgwot
oldhunter wrote:oldhunter wrote:
No ID to vote, but yet when I go to the eye doctor they tell me to bring my medicare card, my supplemental insurance card and a photo ID. All so when I went to get laser surgery on my eye the surgery center wanted the same. When I asked about it, the reason was all the fraud going on in medicare. So us old duffers have to have a photo ID to go to a doctor, but we can't seem to find one to vote?Careful. This is the same reasoning used by people who want to see more restrictions on gun rights. "I have to get a license to drive a car, why not to buy a gun?!?" So make sure you're consistent in your reasoning. Likewise, there are plenty of other parallels. How much do you want to limit the exercise of liberties of the law abiding to protect against bad actors who abuse their freedom? Are you comfortable with more government record keeping to prevent malfeasance?
Icmgwot
That's weird. I bought two new guns this last month and had to show my drivers license both times. I cannot think of a time when I didn't have to show my drivers license to buy a gun. Every time I've filled out a Back ground check I've had to show my drivers license. I'll admit one time I didn't, he asked for my PTP.
Posts: 18 [View]
Joined: Wed Feb 06, 2013 6:44 pm
The question is, are you comfortable with having the same requirements for your guns as you are for other activities? If you accept that voting and getting eye surgery should have similar restrictions, do you feel the same when people equate gun ownership/usage with driving a car? Do you feel you should have a license for one, simply because you do the other?Back In Black wrote:oldhunter wrote:That's weird. I bought two new guns this last month and had to show my drivers license both times. I cannot think of a time when I didn't have to show my drivers license to buy a gun. Every time I've filled out a Back ground check I've had to show my drivers license. I'll admit one time I didn't, he asked for my PTP.
Every time I buy ammo I have to show my ID.
Icmgwot wrote:Careful. This is the same reasoning used by people who want to see more restrictions on gun rights. "I have to get a license to drive a car, why not to buy a gun?!?" So make sure you're consistent in your reasoning. Likewise, there are plenty of other parallels. How much do you want to limit the exercise of liberties of the law abiding to protect against bad actors who abuse their freedom? Are you comfortable with more government record keeping to prevent malfeasance?
MXGreg wrote: just like you need a PTC to carry a gun.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 10 guests