I have a V-LINE Top Drawer (
http://vlineind.com/ProductDetail.php?product_id=27). I did a lot of research and tried out a number of options at various stores before getting this safe. I'm very happy with my purchase. My reasons for going with this safe include:
1. No electronics to fail. No batteries to change.
Originally I was going to get a biometric safe. There are some neat options, but electronic can fail, batteries need to be changed. Also, I've used various biometric devices for over a decade. For doors, time-stamped logins, on my computer, and on my smart phone. The technology has greatly improved, but it is not perfect. Even if it doesn't fail, if you are woken by door being kicked in at night, with your adrenaline pumping at the same time as waking from a deep sleep, you are more likely to mis-position your fingers on the finger print reader. I think biometric safes are a great choice for gun safes to keep your collection, hunting rifles, or guns that you you will not need to get to in a self-defense emergency. I wouldn't rely on them for bedside self-defense.
2. No key.
Not only do I not want to fumble for a key in the dark in an emergency, I'm terrible about misplacing my keys. But not only do I not want to rely on a key, I DON'T WANT THE OPTION of a key. A key is something my young children or their friend could find. Yes, I drill gun safety and respect into my young boy. YES, it is my responsibility to make sure they could never get at the keys. But I know my weaknesses and I know how good kids can be at finding what you think you hid well. Not having a key as an option is just safer and more convenient for me.
3. Secure Enough
My bedside gun safe is a balance between security and quick access. Obviously, not putting it in a safe allows for the quickest access. But I have two young kids and despite my training them, I don't want to have to rely on that. Also, I want to minimize any change of my wife or I causing a negligent discharge (if I wasn't worried about kids, I would have some sore of holster rigged to the side of the dresser near the bed or something.
This isn't about security from theft. A determined thieve with a crow bar could detach the safe from its mounts and run off with it to smash open elsewhere. But they would still need to find it and be willing to take the time, where they could be spending time grabbing jewelry or electronics and getting the hell out.
Again, the security here is to keep my kids or their friends from ever having access.
4. Easy to operate in pitch-black darkness.
My safe uses a simplex lock. I can enter the combo by feel. I don't have to be able to see any numbers. I've practiced this many, many times, including setting an alarm for the middle of the night so I have to get into the safe from a deep sleep. There is no other safe I have that comes close to the speed of access that I have with this safe. Some high-end biometric safes may be a bit quicker, I've not tested them in realistic scenarios. But I'll trade a second of time to access for the reliability of a simplex lock. Dealing with keys and dials are just too slow for a self-defense bedside lock in my opinion.
5. Decent size.
I store a Springfield XDM 9mm with a Crimson Trace Lightguard as my primary home-defense pistol and I put my Glock 42 in its keydex pocket holster in it after I've locked down the house for the evening.
I'm reconsidering this approach though. My though was that in case of a breakin, I could grab the Springfield and, if time allows, put the glock in my pocket as a backup.
Now I'm thinking that I will get another safe and put it in my guest room. My springfield will remain in the safe next to my primary bed and the glock will go into an unmounted (so the safe can be move when I have guests staying over) v-line safe in the guest room where I'll put my glock at the end of the day. That way I have quick access to a pistol at night on both levels of my home. Also, I often work late and will crash in the guest room so as not to disturb the wife. This will ensure that I have ready access to a pistol. Similarly, if I'm working downstairs, I won't have to run to safe upstairs.
Also, I find that I can get my gun in hand more quickly if I only have one in the safe. I re-actively take more care grabbing my Springfield when I know my other gun is in the safe, even though the other gun is in a holster, making negligent discharge of it impossible.
DOWNSIDES
I really love the V-line simplex top drawer safe. But there are some downside. It opens by lifting the lid up. So not great for mounting under the bed or on a wall. It works well in a drawer, but then you have the extra step of opening a drawer. It is best place on top of nightstand or dresser. V-line also makes slide-away and desk-mate safes that open from the front. These work on the same principle. But, for me, I find I'm much quick pressing down on the buttons from top and trying to position my hand and finder and push from the front, especially when waking from a deep sleep in the dark. YMMV.
Simplex locks are fairly easily hacked. I you read the literature of various hacking groups, you'll find number tables to practice, that once proficient, will allow someone to fairly quickly get into a simplex lock. A smash and grab type is not likely to known this or take the time, they'll just pry it off the wall or desk and take it to be opened elsewhere with a crow bar. But a dedicated teen-ager could spend spend a couple hours and eventually get into the safe. There are only 1081 practical combinations (not sure if the v-line safes support half presses, but I wouldn't recommend using them in your combo for an emergency gun, your adrenaline will make it hard to have the fine motor control needed to enter half presses as distinct from full presses).
But, again, I'm not using this as my front-door lock, or for the safe to entire collection of guns. I just want quick access to my gun but still make it very difficult for young children to get at it. I believe that a simplex lock it still more secure than lock that uses a key. I've found the V-Line Top Drawer to be the best compromise on ease of access and security. I'd be happy to learn of better options.