I recently ordered a beltman belt and was disappointed.
While the workmanship was great, I was not happy with the quality of the leather.
I have had 3 belts made by Rafter S and they were excellent; I still have a sharkskin belt that still fits me after my weight loss and continue to wear it daily. The other belt I found outstanding was made by Tucker gun leather out of Texas ; except it was 1 1/2" wide and I found that too wide for most of the belt loops on my jeans.
The big difference was the weight of the leather and the beltman belt instructions said not to use leather conditioner. I use Coach leather conditioner on all of my holsters and belts.
What have been your favorites and why?