by Norsesmithy on Wed Mar 30, 2011 7:51 pm
Generally when someone talks about good and bad sources for AR-15 stuff, they aren't talking about specific rifles, but rather the company in general. A "low tier" manufacture probably still makes many more perfectly functional rifles than they make troublesome rifles, it's just that, compared to a "better" company, they would have a higher lemon rate.
I think that DPMS is unfairly maligned in this, though, because they make an enormous number of rifles per year, so even if they have a better "lemon" rate than another large volume manufacturer like Bushmaster, they are still going to dominate the lemon reports.
That's not to say that I think your odds of getting a trouble free rifle from DPMS are as good as the odds from Colt or Bravo or any of the other big name manufacturers who spend more money on rifle testing and quality control.
M4 feed ramps are essentially meaningless in a semiauto rifle, they are just a "nice" feature, so who cares?
Look for proper staking of the bolt carrier key, make sure you have a proper milspec chamber (DPMS chambers are notorious for being slightly tight, even on their 5.56 labeled guns), make sure you've got a good spring and maybe an o-ring kit in your extractor, make sure your trigger pins aren't walking, etc.
Do all the normal function checks.
And maybe run a case or two of ammo through it.
If it works, it's good.