deer pistol poll

Discussion of handguns

yer best pick fer MN deer pistol

S&W .44
7
11%
S&W .357
8
13%
S&W .41, .45, .460, .500
7
11%
T/C
4
6%
Ruger Redhawk/GP100
6
9%
Ruger Blackhawk/Vaquero
10
16%
10mm 1911/EAA/Glock/S&W 610/et. al.
6
9%
other auto (.400 CorBon, .460 Rowland, .50 GI, .45 Super, .45 ACP, .40, .38 Super, et. al.)
3
4%
other revolver (Taurus, Dan Wesson, BFR, et. al.)
1
1%
AR/AK "pistol"
9
14%
 
Total votes : 61

Re: deer pistol poll

Postby Molasses on Tue Aug 30, 2011 7:06 pm

I've shot deer with a Ruger Blackhawk Hunter in .44, a Desert Eagle .50AE, BFR .45-70 and a PC S&W .460 that looks a lot like the one pictured at top above, only the barrel's longer and has an integral scope base (and it has a hole in the underbarrel web and a base of grip stud for sling swivels, too).
Learned from a friend's experience when he used a .500 S&W and wear electronic muffs while hunting with anything I expect to be harsh. Shot a Blackhawk in .30 Carbine at a crow one time without wearing ear protection and had already learned a little bit of that lesson on my own before that.
Longest shot was with the .460 at what later lased out to about 140yds, using a round hay bale with my mittens and other junk on top of it to make a rest nearly as stable as a bench and bags. Had plenty of time to do everything carefully and get it right.
Most fun was stalking one feeding in a hayfield with the Ruger and taking the shot at maybe all of 30yds.

I have an Auto Mag and LAR Grizzly that haven't even seen the woods since I got them. There's also a Century (different company than the outfit as sells CETMEs and such) .45-70 that needs to get game. A .500 S&W that's a near-identical twin to the .460 that hasn't gone hunting yet, despite being the older of the pair. Several other revolvers that could do the job.

However.
I voted T/C, simply because I have over half a dozen Contender barrels suitable for deer. So I'm thinking I should give one of them a try the next time I use a handgun. I've hunted with Contenders several times and have yet to get a deer with one. Missed one with the 7-30 Waters barrel at a distance of about 15 feet a few years back: I was set up to shoot across a ravine and almost got run over by a bunch that came piling through the brush on the side I was on. Turns out you don't see much through a 4X handgun scope at that distance. :oops: Maybe I'll give that barrel another chance or the .30-30, .357 Max, .44 Mag, .35 Rem, .45-70, .30 or .357 Herretts, 7mmTCU and I know I'm forgetting some others that could have a go. I keep toying with the notion of trying to get a deer with the .270REN (.22 Hornet case opened out straight), but legal or not, it seems a bit undersized...
Molasses
 
Posts: 234 [View]
Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 8:11 pm
Location: Anoka

Re: deer pistol poll

Postby Charlie Lima on Wed Aug 31, 2011 4:05 am

I've been hunting whitetail with a Dan Wesson .44 mag for 18yrs and have taken deer all the way out to 125yrds. Although most are shot within 50 yrds. 240 grain hornady xtp have worked great. Practice practice and more practice. Red dot sight sure helps as well.
User avatar
Charlie Lima
 
Posts: 26 [View]
Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2010 8:41 pm

Re: deer pistol poll

Postby SIGP240 on Wed Aug 31, 2011 8:23 am

Do not overlook Ruger's .44M 7.5" SRH with UltraDot paired with 292 gr. HLRFNGC Keith slugs on top of 21.5gr H110:; it prints 6-shot 2" groups at 25 yds. Recoil is remotely "tame", muzzle flash is low with little residue. A second choice is TC 14" 35 Rem 180 gr. Core-Lockt, upgraded with Williams peep rear for those single shot confident.

What's genuinely a head scratcher.....the saying back@ my old home in the Wolverine state....."There's been more deer shot in Michigan with a 22 Long Rifle than the total of all centerfire deer kills" (a direct quote via the local DNR officer)...to elaborate..(real story)..them ol' Cedar Savages in Michigan rake a totally leaf free path to the salt block, rub an apple or carrot on the trees while walking, take their dog, a spare jacket, a beer, talk out loud, both relieve themselves, talk out loud, swap jackets up on a limb and drop the empty beer can and return home. When the season is open, put on the moccasins an' go huntin'! Ja sure, eh?

Moral of story: Ain't the Caliber, it's the shot placement!
Proudly launching lead from a Swiss P-240 at a range near you.
SIGP240
 
Posts: 425 [View]
Joined: Mon Dec 08, 2008 10:05 am

Previous

Return to Handguns

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 12 guests

cron