Re: Kimbers
I own several - some are series two and some aren't. I haven't owned any with the ill-fated external extractor design so I can't really comment on the issues that those created for others.
Let me highlight a couple experiences with Kimbers:
* Ultra CDP II
- Purchased new
- Has functioned flawlessly after the break in period. Break-in issues were primarily related to me limp-wristing the pistol (it's rather snappy)
- This was my previous carry weapon for most of 2009
* Classic CDP II
- Purchased used in 90% condition (my estimate)
- Had a bad desire to fail to return to battery when I first took it to the range, also had extraction issues
- Replaced extractor with new stock part from Wilson Combat - set proper tension
- Replaced recoil spring w/ new Wolff spring at an increased spring strength
- Problem solved
* Pro SIS
- Purchased new
- Have had zero problems with this pistol that weren't of my own creating after break-in period
- I did replace the stock recoil spring with a new Wolff spring out of the box given my experience with the Classic CDP II above
- This is my carry weapon
- I used this gun yesterday in DonL's Defensive Handgun Training class
Like most of you, I own a number of different brands and calibers have handguns - I think the concept of "best" choice is going to be different for different people - and I know that Kimber has had some challenges in the past. I've been quite happy with mine, however, and look forward to buying... more of them

B