by Seismic Sam on Thu May 26, 2011 12:50 pm
As far as the mocking is concerned, everything I said was in dead earnest. He wants to buy a semi-auto VERY expensive .338 Lapua without ANY evidence whatsoever that it will shoot even close as good as a bolt gun. Just some glossy publicity stuff on the internet, and who else has heard of this company before, or knows their reputation, and for that matter, how long have they been in business?
Assuming that there isn't much difference in particle size between big bore powders like RL-19 or RL-25, a 338 Lapua case can hold about 108 grains of RL-25, so 75 grains of a similar (and most importantly, a faster burning powder) like RL-19 is going to leave A LOT of empty space in the case. 75 grains may be the right load for that burn rate, but you're totally neglecting the empty space issue, which could cause a flashover and get all the powder ignited at once, which could blow the gun (and reloading manuals warn in detail about reduced loads in certain rifle calibers).
And lastly, there's the forever red flag of somebody who wants to buy an $8000 gun and says he wants to reload for it, but hasn't gotten around to getting a manual yet, and freely admits he does not know what he is getting himself into. This is not a 30-06 we're talking about here, people, this is a very high power cartridge that is getting into the Mount Everest level of reloading with all the little tricks you have to know, so there's no way in hell he can possibly get everything right as a rookie.
And yes, he DOES have a pretty bad case of gun lust in his heart if he wants to run out and spend $8k on this thing, and he REALLY does need to take a very big chill pill, and read up on the 338 Lapua in detail before he puts his money on the counter.
I didn't say he was stupid, I didn't say he was making a bad firearms choice, I didn't call him a n00b, and all I really pointed out that he was getting into some pretty serious deep water with reloading for a gun like this, and he didn't have his ducks even close to being in a row to make an informed purchasing decison. Considering the reaction from some of you, I'm sorry I even replied to this thread to begin with. Next time something like this comes up, I'll just keep my mouth shut and wait for the sound of something blowing up.
As far as providing all the necessary "mentoring" for a cartridge like this, it would take literally several days to pull everything together and type it all out, and I'm not going to take that much time to try and teach a complete novice about reloading at a level that has taken me decades to learn. That would be like me going to Steven Hawking and asking him to teach me everything he knows about black holes and 10-dimensional superstring theory.